Ecological Archives E088-167-A1

Arne Janssen, Maurice W. Sabelis, Sara Magalhães, Marta Montserrat, and Tessa van der Hammen. 2007. Habitat structure affects intraguild predation. Ecology 88:2713–2719.

Appendix A. Effects of intraguild predation on the intraguild prey and shared prey in unstructured vs. structured habitats and in habitats categorized according to structure.

TABLE A1. Effects of intraguild predation on the intraguild prey and shared prey in unstructured vs. structured habitats.

       

Intraguild prey

Shared prey

 

Authors

IG-predator

IG-prey

Shared prey

L (unstr)

L (struct)

L (unstr)

L (struct)

Best competitor§

Finke and Denno (2002)

spider

predatory bug

planthopper

-2.20

-0.23

3.50

0.77

IG-prey

Finke and Denno (2006)

spider

predatory bug

planthopper

-0.89

-0.41

-0.06

-1.49

IG-prey

Gilinsky (1984)

fish

midge

midge

-1.70

-0.95

-0.54

-0.49

?

Griffen and Byers (2006)

crab

crab

amphipod

 
 

0.10

-0.08

IG-prey

Harvey and Eubanks (2005)

fire ant

parasitoids

caterpillar

-0.07

0.04

0.03

0.54

?

       
 
 
 
 
 

Hershey (1985)

fish

midge

midge

-0.52

0.23

-0.42

0.09

?

Mallampalli et al. (2002)

soldier bug

ladybeetle

beetle

 
 

0.18

-0.35

IG-prey

Snyder and Ives (2001)

carabid

parasitoid

aphid

-2.58

-0.21

-0.49

-0.29

IG-prey

Snyder and Ives (2001)

carabid

parasitoid

aphid

-0.75

-0.97

-0.14

0.84

IG-prey

Warfe and Barmuta (2004)

fish

damselfly

mosquito

-0.03

0.03

-0.90

-0.67

?

† The effect size in the habitat without spatial structure, see text for the method of calculating L .

‡ The effect size in the habitat with spatial structure.

§ Indicates whether the intraguild prey (IG-prey) or the intraguild predator (IG-predator) was the best competitor for the shared prey, ?: the study does not contain information on the best competitor.

 

TABLE A2. Effects of intraguild predation on the intraguild prey and shared prey in habitats categorized according to structure.

       

IG-prey

Shared

   

Authors

IG-predator

IGprey

Shared prey

L

L

Best competitor

Structure

Bence (1988)

fish

predatory insects

mosquitos

-3.26

-4.92

IG-predator

2

Blaustein (1992)

fish

predatory bug

mosquitos

-0.23

-0.95

IG-predator

2

Blaustein (1992)

fish

predatory bug

mosquitos

-0.32

-0.59

IG-predator

2

Blaustein (1992)

fish

predatory bug

mosquitos

-0.23

-0.66

IG-predator

2

Blaustein (1992)

fish

predatory bug

mosquitos

-0.32

0.27

IG-predator

2

       
 
 
 
 

Colfer and Rosenheim (2001)

lady beetle

parasitoid

aphid

-4.84

-8.27

IG-predator

1

Colfer et al. (2003)

predatory bug

predatory mite

spider mite

-5.16

-4.28

?

1

Colfer et al. (2003)

predatory bug

predatory mite

spider mite

-1.45

-0.52

?

1

Crumrine and Crowley (2003)

dragonfly

dragonfly

fish

-0.98

0.23

IG-predator

1

Crumrine (2005)

dragonfly

dragonfly

damselfly

-1.13

-1.47

IG-predator

2

       
 
 
 
 

Denno et al. (2004)

spider

spider

planthopper

-1.21

-0.77

IG-predator

1

Denno et al. (2004)

spider

spider

planthopper

-1.28

-0.75

IG-predator

1

Denno et al. (2004)

spider

spider

planthopper

-0.46

-1.29

IG-predator

2

Diehl and Feissel (2001)

ciliate

ciliate

bacteria

-3.68

-0.88

IG-prey

1

Dinter (2002)

spider

lacewing

aphid

-0.57

-0.10

IG-predator

1

       
 
 
 
 

Dinter (2002)

spider

lacewing

aphid

-0.35

-0.38

IG-prey

1

Erbilgin et al. (2004)

predatory bug

parasitoid

psyllid

-1.52

-0.32

IG-prey

1

Ferguson and Stiling (1996)

lady beetle

parasitoid

aphid

-0.56

0.22

IG-prey

2

Finke and Denno (2002)

spider

predatory bug

planthopper

-3.64

2.59

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

spider

planthopper

 

0.56

IG-predator

1

       
 
 
 
 

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

lady beetle

planthopper

 

0.66

IG-predator

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug

planthopper

 

0.43

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug

planthopper

 

0.37

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug

planthopper

 

-0.41

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug + spider

planthopper

 

-1.18

IG-predator

1

       
 
 
 
 

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug + spider

planthopper

 

-0.25

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug + spider

planthopper

 

-0.62

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug + lady beetle

planthopper

 

-0.72

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug + lady beetle

planthopper

 

-0.49

IG-prey

1

Finke and Denno (2005)

spider

predatory bug + lady beetle

planthopper

 

-0.49

IG-prey

1

       
 
 
 
 

Gonzalez and Tessier (1997)

fish

midge

daphnid

-1.22

0.89

IG-prey

2

Heinz and Nelson (1996)

beetle

parasitoid

whitefly

 

0.10

IG-predator

2

Heinz and Nelson (1996)

beetle

parasitoid

whitefly

 

-1.54

IG-predator

2

Huang and Sih (1991)

sunfish

salamander

isopod

-0.59

-2.74

IG-prey

1

Lang (2003)

carabids

spiders

aphids

0.02

0.28

IG-predator

2

       
 
 
 
 

Lawler and Morin (1993)

ciliate

ciliate

bacteria

-2.24

 

?

1

Lawler and Morin (1993)

ciliate

ciliate

bacteria

-1.46

 

?

1

Menge et al. (1986)

fish and crabs

gastropods

molluscs

-1.51

-0.52

IG-predator

2

Moran and Hurd (1994)

mantid

various

homoptera

 

-0.17

?

2

Moran and Hurd (1994)

mantid

various

diptera

 

-0.04

?

2

       
 
 
 
 

Moran and Hurd (1994)

mantid

various

hemiptera

 

-0.16

?

2

Morin (1984)

fish

dragonflies

various

-0.90

-0.53

?

2

Morin (1999)

ciliate

ciliate

bacteria

-0.68

 

?

1

Okyuyama (2002)

spider

spider

diptera

 

0.24

?

1

Pacala and Roughgarden (1984)

lizards

spiders

diptera

-2.70

-0.95

?

2

       
 
 
 
 

Polis and McCormick (1986)

scorpion

spiders

various

-0.61

-0.01

?

2

Polis and McCormick (1987)

scorpion

scorpions

scorpion

-0.30

-0.05

?

2

Posey and Hines (1991)

shrimp

anemone

polychaete

-1.39

-0.42

?

2

Rosenheim (2001)

spider

lacewing

aphid

-0.12

-0.83

IG-predator

1

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-0.12

-0.96

IG-predator

1

       
 
 
 
 

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-0.49

-0.37

IG-predator

1

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-2.19

0.07

IG-prey

1

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-2.95

0.93

IG-prey

1

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

0.00

0.18

IG-prey

1

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

0.88

1.58

IG-prey

1

       
 
 
 
 

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

0.95

0.96

IG-prey

1

Rosenheim (2001)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

1.33

1.96

IG-prey

1

Rosenheim (2005)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-0.25

 

?

 

Rosenheim (2005)

predatory bug

predatory bug

various

-0.94

 

?

2

Rosenheim (2005)

predatory bug

predatory bug

various

-0.89

 

?

2

       
 
 
 
 

Rosenheim (2005)

lacewing

predatory bug

various

-1.18

 

?

2

Rosenheim et al. (2004)

spider

predatory mite

spider mite

-0.50

-0.35

IG-prey

2

Rosenheim et al. (2004)

spider

beetle

spider mite

 

-0.57

IG-prey

2

Rosenheim et al. (1993)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-0.85

0.24

IG-prey

1

Rosenheim et al. (1993)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-3.85

0.97

IG-prey

1

       
 
 
 
 

Rosenheim et al. (1993)

predatory bug

lacewing

aphid

-3.85

1.70

IG-prey

1

Snyder and Ives (2003)

various

parasitoid

aphid

0.89

-1.32

IG-prey

2

Snyder and Wise (1999)

spiders and carabids

various

various

0.10

0.06

?

2

Snyder and Wise (1999)

spiders and carabids

various

various

-0.72

-1.31

?

2

Snyder et al. (2004)

lady beetle

parasitoid

aphid

-0.29

-1.34

?

2

       
 
 
 
 

Spiller and Schoener (1988)

lizards

spiders

arthropods

-1.15

-0.16

IG-prey

2

Spiller and Schoener (1994)

lizards

spiders

arthropods

-0.37

-0.02

IG-prey

2

Venzon et al. (2001)

predatory bug

predatory mite

spider mite

0.09

0.19

IG-prey

2

Wise and Chen (1999)

various arthropods

spiders

beetle

-0.25

0.33

?

2

Wissinger and McGrady (1993)

dragonfly

dragonfly

damselfly

-0.34

-0.32

IG-prey

1

Wissinger and McGrady (1993)

dragonfly

dragonfly

damselfly

-0.32

0.14

IG-prey

2

† Spatial structure was categorized, see text for details. Other columns are explained at Table A1.

 

LITERATURE CITED

Bence, J. R. 1988. Indirect effects and biological control of mosquitos by mosquitofish. Journal of Applied Ecology 25:505–521.

Blaustein, L. 1992. Larvivorous fishes fail to control mosquitos in experimental rice plots. Hydrobiologia 232:219–232.

Colfer, R. G., and J. A. Rosenheim. 2001. Predation on immature parasitoids and its impact on aphid suppression. Oecologia 126:292–304.

Colfer, R. G., J. A. Rosenheim, L. D. Godfrey, and C. L. Hsu. 2003. Interactions between the augmentatively released predaceous mite Galendromus occidentalis (Acari: Phytoseiidae) and naturally occurring generalist predators. Environmental Entomology 32:840–852.

Crumrine, P. W. 2005. Size structure and substitutability in an odonate intraguild predation system. Oecologia 145:132–139.

Crumrine, P. W., and P. H. Crowley. 2003. Partitioning components of risk reduction in a dragonfly-fish intraguild predation system. Ecology 84:1588–1597.

Denno, R. F., M. S. Mitter, G. A. Langellotto, C. Gratton, and D. L. Finke. 2004. Interactions between a hunting spider and a web-builder: consequences of intraguild predation and cannibalism for prey suppression. Ecological Entomology 29:566–577.

Diehl, S., and M. Feissel. 2001. Intraguild prey suffer from enrichment of their resources: A microcosm experiment with ciliates. Ecology 82:2997–2983.

Dinter, A. 2002. Microcosm studies on intraguild predation between female erigonid spiders and lacewing larvae and influence of single versus multiple predators on cereal aphids. Journal Of Applied Entomology 126:249–257.

Erbilgin, N., D. L. Dahlsten, and P. Y. Chen. 2004. Intraguild interactions between generalist predators and an introduced parasitoid of Glycaspis brimblecobei (Homoptera: Psylloidae). Biological Control 31:329–337.

Ferguson , K. I., and P. Stiling. 1996. Non additive effects of multiple natural enemies on aphid populations. Oecologia 108:375–379.

Finke, D. L., and R. F. Denno. 2002. Intraguild predation diminsihed in complex-structured vegetation: implications for prey suppression. Ecology 83:643–652.

Finke, D. L., and R. F. Denno. 2005. Predator diversity and the functioning of ecosystems: the role of intraguild predation in dampening trophic cascades. Ecology Letters 8:1299–1306.

Finke, D. L., and R. F. Denno. 2006. Spatial refuge from intraguild predation: implications for prey suppression and trophic cascades. Oecologia 149:265–275.

Gilinsky, E. 1984. The role of fish predation and spatial heterogeneity in determining benthic community structure. Ecology 65:455–468.

Gonzalez, M. J., and A. J. Tessier. 1997. Habitat segregation and interactive effects of multiple predators on a prey assemblage. Freshwater Biology 38:179–191.

Griffen, B. D., and J. E. Byers. 2006. Partitioning mechanisms of predator interference in different habitats. Oecologia 146:608–614.

Harvey, C. T., and M. D. Eubanks. 2005. Intraguild predation of parasitoids by Solenopsis invicta: a non-disruptive interaction. Entomologia Experimentalis Et Applicata 114:127–135.

Heinz, K. M., and J. M. Nelson. 1996. Interspecific interactions among natural enemies of Bemisia tabaci in an inundative biological control program. Biologcal Control 6:384–393.

Hershey, A. E. 1985. Effects of predatory sculpin on the chironomid communities in an arctic lake. Ecology 66:1131–1138.

Huang, C., and A. Sih. 1991. Experimental studies on direct and indirect interactions in a three trophic-level stream system. Oecologia 85:530–536.

Lang, A. 2003. Intraguild interference and biocontrol effects of generalist predators in a winter wheat field. Oecologia 134:144–153.

Lawler, S. P., and P. J. Morin. 1993. Food web architecture and population dynamics in laboratory microcosms of protists. American Naturalist 141:675–686.

Mallampalli, N., I. Castellanos, and P. Barbosa. 2002. Evidence for intraguild predation by Podisus maculiventris on a ladybeetle, Coleomegilla maculata: Implications for biological control of Colorado potato beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata. Biocontrol 47:387–398.

Menge, B. A., J. Lubchenco, S. D. Gaines, and L. R. Ashkenas. 1986. A test of the Menge-Sutherland model of community organization in a tropical rocky intertidal food web. Oecologia 71:75–89.

Moran, M. D., and L. E. Hurd. 1994. Short-term responses to elevated predator densities: noncompetitive intraguild interactions and behavior. Oecologia 98:269–273.

Morin, P. J. 1984. The impact of fish exclusion on the abundance and species composition of larval odonates: results of short-term experiments in a North Carolina farm pond. Ecology 65:53–60.

Morin, P. J. 1999. Productivity, intraguild predation, and population dynamics in experimental food webs. Ecology 80:752–760.

Okuyama, T. 2002. The role of antipredator behavior in an experimental community of jumping spiders with intraguild predation. Population Ecology 44:121–125.

Pacala, S. W., and J. Roughgarden. 1984. Control of arthropod abundance by Anolis lizards on St. Eustatius (Neth. Antilles). Oecologia 64:160–162.

Polis, G. A., and S. J. McCormick. 1986. Scorpions, spiders and solpugids: predation and competition among distantly related taxa. Oecologia 71:111–116.

Polis, G. A., and S. J. McCormick. 1987. Intraguild predation and competition among desert scorpions. Ecology 68:332–343.

Posey, M. H., and A. H. Hines. 1991. Complex predatory-prey interactions within an estuarine benthic community. Ecology 72:2155–2169.

Rosenheim , J. A. 2001. Source-sink dynamics for a generalist insect predator in habitats with strong higher-order predation. Ecological Monographs 71:93–116.

Rosenheim , J. A. 2005. Intraguild predation of Orius tristicolor by Geocoris spp. and the paradox of irruptive spider mite dynamics on California cotton. Biological Control 32:172–179.

Rosenheim , J. A., T. E. Glik, R. E. Goeriz, and B. Rämert. 2004. Linking a predator's foraging behavior with its effects on herbivore population suppression. Ecology 85:3362–3372.

Rosenheim , J. A., L. R. Wilhoit, and C. A. Armer. 1993. Influence of intraguild predation among generalist insect predators on the suppression of an herbivore population. Oecologia 96:439–449.

Snyder, W. E., S. N. Ballard, S. Yang, G. M. Clevenger, T. D. Miller, J. J. Ahn, T. D. Hatten, and A. A. Berryman. 2004. Complementary biocontrol of aphids by the ladybird beetle Harmonia axyridis and the parasitoid Aphelinus asychis on greenhouse roses. Biological Control 30:229–235.

Snyder, W. E., and A. R. Ives. 2001. Generalist predators disrupt biological control by a specialist parasitoid. Ecology 82:705–716.

Snyder, W. E., and A. R. Ives. 2003. Interactions between specialist and generalist natural enemies: Parasitoids, predators, and pea aphid biocontrol. Ecology 84:91–107.

Snyder, W. E., and D. H. Wise. 1999. Predator interference and the establishment of generalist predator populations for biocontrol. Biological Control 15:283–292.

Spiller, D. A., and T. W. Schoener. 1988. An experimental study of the effect of lizards on web-spider communities. Ecological Monographs 58:57–77.

Spiller, D. A., and T. W. Schoener. 1994. Effects of top and intermediate predators in a terrestrial food web. Ecology 75:182–196.

Venzon, M., A. Janssen, and M. W. Sabelis. 2001. Prey preference, intraguild predation and population dynamics of an arthropod food web on plants. Experimental and Applied Acarology 25:785–808.

Warfe, D. M., and L. A. Barmuta. 2004. Habitat structural complexity mediates the foraging success of multiple predator species. Oecologia 141:171–178.

Wise, D. H., and B. Chen. 1999. Impact of intraguild predators on survival of a forest-floor wolf spider. Oecologia 121:129–137.

Wissinger, S., and J. McGrady. 1993. Intraguild predation and competition between larval dragonflies: direct and indirect effects on shared prey. Ecology 74:207–218.



[Back to E088-167]