Appendix E. Nitrogen use efficiency and N response efficiency (NRE) in leaves and wood of dominant shrub species in response to nutrient addition in the bog, the intermediate fen, and the rich fen.
|
|
AN |
MRTN |
NUE |
N uptake efficiency |
NRE |
|||||||||||||||
(g new biomass·
|
(years) |
(g new biomass/
|
(g N uptake·
|
(g new biomass·
|
|||||||||||||||||
Leaves |
Wood |
Leaves |
Wood |
Leaves |
Wood |
Leaves |
Wood |
Leaves |
Wood |
||||||||||||
C. calyculata |
|||||||||||||||||||||
(Bog) |
|||||||||||||||||||||
Control |
5,5 |
19 |
± 5a |
26 |
± 3a |
4.4 |
± 1.0a |
4.7 |
± 0.5a |
64 |
± 2a |
118 |
± 6b |
1.8 |
± 0.4a |
0.9 |
± 0.2b |
111 |
± 28a |
102 |
± 20a |
Nitrogen |
5,5 |
29 |
± 3 |
9 |
± 2*** |
2.5 |
± 0.2 |
11.8 |
± 1.4*** |
71 |
± 3 |
103 |
± 8 |
0.4 |
± 0.1** |
0.1 |
± 0.02*** |
26 |
± 5** |
9 |
± 2*** |
Phosphorus |
5,5 |
33 |
± 1 |
28 |
± 4 |
1.8 |
± 0.1 |
3.4 |
± 0.3* |
62 |
±2** |
92 |
± 4** |
0.9 |
± 0.1 |
0.3 |
± 0.1† |
53 |
± 8 |
30 |
± 6 |
N+P |
5,5 |
17 |
± 5** |
9 |
± 1 |
4.3 |
± 1.0** |
10.1 |
± 0.6 |
56 |
± 3* |
92 |
± 5 |
0.7 |
± 0.2* |
0.2 |
± 0.1*** |
40 |
± 15 |
22 |
± 5*** |
Alnus rugosa |
|||||||||||||||||||||
(Int. fen) |
|||||||||||||||||||||
Control |
5,5 |
41 |
± 1a |
5 |
± 1b |
1 |
|
23.3 |
± 6.7 |
41 |
± 1a |
79 |
± 5b |
1.3 |
± 0.8a |
0.1 |
± 0.1b |
52 |
± 29a |
12 |
± 8b |
Nitrogen |
4,4 |
41 |
± 2 |
6 |
± 2 |
1 |
|
16.7 |
± 6.7 |
41 |
± 2 |
68 |
± 4 |
0.8 |
± 0.7*** |
0.1 |
± 0.1* |
30 |
± 24** |
6 |
± 5* |
Phosphorus |
4,4 |
38 |
± 2** |
8 |
± 1 |
1 |
|
9.0 |
± 1.4† |
38 |
± 2** |
67 |
± 4* |
19.7 |
± 2.2*** |
1.9 |
± 0.6*** |
744 |
± 58*** |
123 |
± 37*** |
N+P |
4,5 |
39 |
± 2 |
8 |
± 3 |
1 |
|
12.6 |
± 5.2 |
39 |
± 2 |
59 |
± 6 |
3.3 |
± 1.1** |
0.9 |
± 0.4* |
129 |
± 48† |
42 |
± 16 |
Alnus rugosa |
|||||||||||||||||||||
(Rich fen) |
|||||||||||||||||||||
Control |
3,2 |
42 |
± 1a |
23 |
± 2b |
1 |
|
3.3 |
± 0.2 |
42 |
± 1a |
76 |
± 12b |
0.1 |
± 0.1a |
0.1 |
± 0.1a |
6 |
± 3a |
4 |
± 3a |
Nitrogen |
4,2 |
44 |
± 1 |
13 |
± 4* |
1 |
|
5.8 |
± 2.1* |
44 |
± 1 |
69 |
± 7 |
0.1 |
± 0.1*** |
0.01 |
± 0.001* |
4 |
± 2** |
1 |
± 0.2* |
Phosphorus |
4,4 |
37 |
± 2** |
8 |
± 1** |
1 |
|
8.0 |
± 1.4** |
37 |
± 2** |
56 |
± 2* |
8.1 |
± 1.9*** |
0.9 |
±0.2*** |
291 |
± 61*** |
49 |
± 9*** |
N+P |
3,2 |
37 |
± 2 |
5 |
± 0 |
1 |
|
13.7 |
± 1.7 |
37 |
± 2 |
63 |
± 5 |
2.1 |
± 1.5** |
0.3 |
± 0.2* |
73 |
± 50† |
20 |
± 8 |
Notes: Data are mean ± 1 SE with sample size "n" (leaves, wood) in the following treatments: Control, N addition, P addition, and combined N and P addition (N+P).†P < 0.10; *P < 0.05; **P < 0.01 and ***P < 0.001 for the effect of nutrient addition within a species and tissue type; asterisks next to the “N+P” treatment signify a significant interaction between N and P. Letters indicate differences between tissue type in the control treatment (P < 0.10) for each parameter and species. For information on abbreviations, see Table 2.